Table 21

Evidence review summary for ‘Which surgical approach provides the best clinical outcomes?’

Clinical outcomeSummary of evidence review (VATS vs thoracotomy) (95% CI)
Length of hospital stay2.3 days shorter (1.2 to 3.4) with VATS
Need for repeat interventionNo difference and very low for both (≈35/1000)*
Patient symptomsLess postoperative pain with VATS†
ComplicationsLess with VATS (152/1000 patients (138 to 167) compared with 197/1000*
Quality of lifeNot reported in any study
MortalitySlightly lower with VATS (35/1000 (29 to 42) compared with 47/1000)*
  • *Meta-analysis results reported as per 1000 patients.

  • †Meta-analysis not possible, data reported in different formats.

  • VATS, video-assisted thoracoscopy surgery.